Critic's Choice

Critic's Choice is an engaging comedy film from 1963 starring the dynamic duo of Bob Hope and Lucille Ball. Directed by veteran filmmaker Don Weis, and based on the comic play by Ira Levin, the film is a sparkling blend of humor, charm, and vivacious screen performances.

The film tells the story of New York theater critic Parker Ballantine, played with characteristic flair by Bob Hope. As a critic, Parker is uncompromising and brutally honest and has earned a reputation for his biting reviews. He's a celebrated figure in the New York theater setting, his reviews influencing the lifespan of theatre productions and shaping the public opinion on theater works.

Parker’s life takes an interesting twist when his wife, Angela Ballantine, portrayed by the ever-lively Lucille Ball, decides to try her hand at playwriting. Being the loving husband, Parker supports Angela in her creative pursuit but finds himself caught in a bind when he has to review her play.

The prospect of reviewing his wife’s work puts Parker in an interesting predicament. As a renowned critic, he is all about maintaining his integrity and refusing to have his judgment clouded by his personal relationships. But as a loving husband and wishing to support his wife in her endeavors, Parker finds himself torn between his professional duty and personal relationships.

Parker's dilemma provides plenty of comic fodder as Bob Hope masterfully balances his duty as a critic with maintaining the peace at home, punctuated by superb comedic timing and a sharp wit.

Lucille Ball as Angela, likewise, proves why she is one of the greatest comedic actresses of her time. She balances vulnerability with ambition, and innocence with tenacity, as she hopes to prove her talent in playwriting, give life to her creative vision, and earn critical acclaim, particularly from her husband.

Actress Marilyn Maxwell plays the role of Ivy London, a successful and attractive Broadway star who previously had been romantically involved with Parker. Her involvement in the situation adds to the layers of complexity and humor, bringing more laughs and a hint of tension considering the romantic history with Parker.

The witty script of Critic's Choice reflects Ira Levin's astute sense of humor and a keen understanding of the theater world's foibles, as reflected in a critic having to judge his wife's work. The sharp dialogues and smart repartee are well handled by the experienced cast who bring an unmistakable comic energy to the proceedings.

Don Weis’s direction flows with the tone of the movie and never lets the narrative lose its charm or momentum. He smartly handles the comic tension and frequently hilarious dialogue, maintaining an entertaining balance throughout the film.

What also impresses is the recreation of the 1963 New York City theater environment with significant attention to detail and authenticity. Certainly, the audience is made to feel that they are witnessing the hustle and bustle of this vibrant theater world, portraying a sense of what it was like to be part of the theater milieu in the 60s.

Critic's Choice is an entertaining insight into how personal and professional boundaries often blur and the humorous consequences that result from it. The superbly crafted characters, witty dialogues, captivating plot, and brilliant performances by the cast make Critic's Choice a film worth watching. Its humor and charm sustained more than half a century after its release, presenting a delightful snapshot of the theater world of the era through an amusing family drama.

In summary, Critic's Choice is a charming comedy filled with witty dialogues and humorous situations. The performances of Bob Hope, Lucille Ball, and the rest of the cast help elevate the film, making it a worthy entry in the comedy genre. Both an entertaining look at theater criticism and a nostalgic trip back to the vibrant theater scene of New York in the 1960s, the film offers laughs and charm in equal measure.