Hex Hollow: Witchcraft and Murder in Pennsylvania

Hex Hollow: Witchcraft and Murder in Pennsylvania is a compelling and captivating documentary released in 2015. Directed by Shane Free, this haunting tale explores the intersection of religion, faith, local folklore, superstition, and the tragic incident of murder that unfolded in the heart of the rural community of York County, Pennsylvania.

Without providing any spoilers, it's safe to say that the film takes the audience on a history-packed journey, starting from the tranquil pre-industrial era, gradually hinting at the looming darkness that's about to descend on the seemingly peaceful community. Hex Hollow dwells on describing the cultural fabric of York County, an area still united by Pennsylvania Dutch heritage and beliefs during the early 20th century.

Amidst the community were individuals who had held onto the customs embedded in Pow-wow, a traditional healing ritual drawn from a blend of spiritualism, Christianity, and rituals of the Pennsylvania Dutch. The concept of witchcraft was intrinsically tied to Pow-wow, and an array of people in the community bore the title of Braucher, or practitioners.

This backdrop sets the stage for the main cast, comprised of historian J. Ross McGinnis, devotee Rickie Ebaugh, and occultist Christopher Bilardi. Their voices provide a structured narrative and genuinely present the braided aspects of culture, belief, superstition, and the legalities surrounding the dark events that took place.

Enter Nelson Rehmeyer, a locally renowned Pow-wow practitioner with an ominous reputation within the community of being a witch. Portrayed as a deeply enigmatic figure who lived a secluded life, he was entwined in a web of folklore and superstition that left a pervasive influence on the local people, ultimately leading to an unfortunate and tragic event - his murder.

While highlighting this murder is central to the film’s plotline, Hex Hollow goes beyond merely recounting the grim facts of the case. It masterfully constructs a rich historical context, taking viewers on a journey back to a time when the lines between folklore and reality were blurred. Simultaneously, it raises intriguing questions about justice, superstition, belief, and the murkiness that surrounds incidents when they are judged not only from a lawful standpoint but also from superstition's lens.

The filmmakers pay meticulous attention to delivering a well-researched documentary, drawing upon a vast number of primary sources. This includes court records, local newspapers, and personal testimonies from descendants of those involved in the horrific events. The film integrates these components to form a coherent narrative that's as sensitive as it is riveting, steering clear of making careless assumptions or taking a sensationalist approach to the story. It refrains from demonizing or victimizing people involved, ensuring an unbiased view.

Featuring interviews with Rehmeyer’s descendants as well as with present-day folk practitioners, the documentary casts a sincere light on the long-lasting impacts of the murder on the community and the descendants of those involved. From personal guilt to the stigma associated with being related to the case, Hex Hollow grapples with the consequences of a single event and its far-reaching implications, even decades later.

Visually speaking, Hex Hollow is a cinematic treat. The stunning shots of York County, the meticulous recreations of the period, and the evocative cinematographic choices contribute to the storytelling, the atmospheric tension, and the deeply-seated aura of mysticism and fear.

Intriguing, chilling, and thoroughly researched, Hex Hollow: Witchcraft and Murder in Pennsylvania offers an immersive exploration into a unique period of history where folklore held sway over people’s minds and actions. While the murder case is its focal point, the film exceeds expectations by delicately unearthing the cultural, historical, and personal facets of the tragedy, delving into the heart of the matter and the repercussions that ripple outwards. A must-watch for history enthusiasts, true crime fans, and those interested in exploring the potent power of belief and cultural superstition.