It Happened on Fifth Avenue

It Happened on Fifth Avenue is a warm and delightful holiday film from the late 1940s. Released in 1947, this American comedy was directed by Roy Del Ruth and features a beloved cast including Don DeFore, Ann Harding, and Charles Ruggles. The film captures the spirit of the season while touching upon themes of friendship, family, and the complex matters of the human heart. It Happened on Fifth Avenue is a hidden gem that truly resonates with the holiday spirit and showcases the charm of a bygone era in American cinema.

The story unfolds in the opulent but deserted mansion of the immensely wealthy Michael J. O'Connor (Charles Ruggles), the second richest man in the world. Every winter, O'Connor departs his swanky Fifth Avenue mansion to vacation in the warmer climes of the South, leaving his luxurious home uninhabited. Enter Aloysius T. McKeever (Victor Moore), a genial and homeless man who has spent the past few winters secretly occupying O'Connor's mansion. McKeever takes advantage of O'Connor's absence and utilizes the deserted mansion to gain shelter from the New York winter.

On a particularly chilly night, McKeever crosses paths with Jim Bullock (Don DeFore), an unemployed war veteran. In his signature kind-hearted manner, McKeever offers Bullock refuge, providing him with a way out of the cold and into the warmth of O'Connor's vast mansion. Eventually, the pair welcome more homeless veterans, each facing the challenges of post-war unemployment and contrasting socio-economic disparities.

The plot takes a humorous twist when O’Connor’s daughter, Trudy (Gale Storm), unknowingly arrives at the mansion, mistaking the pair for her family’s staff. Intrigued by the duo's generosity and unknowing of their true identities, Trudy decides to play along, introducing herself under an assumed identity. Things get even more interesting when she develops romantic feelings for Jim, complicating the situation.

In the meantime, O'Connor himself, unaware of the entire scenario, returns to New York and decides to take a personal interest in the homeless problem. He lands up at his mansion in disguise where McKeever, in blissful ignorance, welcomes him to stay, thinking he's another down-on-his-luck individual. We thus see an endearing shift in dynamics, offering comic situations, heartfelt instances, and insightful commentary on societal values.

Director Roy Del Ruth does a splendid job of weaving the film's hilarious and warm-hearted sequences together. The comedy is kept light and fresh, supported by the underlying message of goodwill and compassion. From a quiet Fifth Avenue mansion to a lively home full of homeless veterans and a millionaire in disguise, the film effectively presents the contrast of riches and social disparity, whimsically emphasizing the message of community and human connection.

Don DeFore delivers a charming performance as Jim, successfully capturing the struggles and aspirations of an everyday man grappling with post-war realities. Victor Moore as McKeever shines throughout the movie, seamlessly blending humor and wisdom. Charles Ruggles masterfully portrays O'Connor in a manner that adeptly evokes empathy rather than scorn for the ignorant millionaire. Gale Storm also pulls off a memorable performance as the doe-eyed Trudy, capturing the dynamics of her character and the light-hearted romance exceptionally well.

Cinematography plays a key role in the movie, perfectly capturing the extravagance of the mansion and the stark contrast of the chilly streets of New York. The setting of the grand mansion has been utilized splendidly, making it a character in itself. The screenplay is well-paced, making the twists and turns of the plot vibrant and relatable.

In conclusion, It Happened on Fifth Avenue is more than just a comedy. The movie combines humor, heart, romance, and social commentary, which culminates in an entertaining viewing experience. Despite being set in a different era, audiences today can enjoy its timeless theme - the essence of humanity and the spirit of giving. It's a wonderful film that's sure to give you an enjoyable time and leave you with a heartwarming holiday feel. If you're a fan of charming, good-hearted classics from the golden age of Hollywood, It Happened on Fifth Avenue is a must-watch.