Kept Husbands

Kept Husbands is an engaging journey into the world of societal norms, contrasting lifestyles, and human connections. Produced in 1931, this pre-Code American drama takes a deep dive into class distinctions, intricate relationships, and the choices we make for love. Director Lloyd Bacon masterfully slices the society pie with a buttery story, served generously by the remarkable performances of Clara Kimball Young, Joel McCrea, and Dorothy Mackaill, with supporting roles from Ned Sparks and Mary Carr.

The story reveals itself through the lens of a high-society heiress, Dorothy 'Dot' Parker played by Dorothy Mackaill, and a hardworking blue-collar steel mill worker, Richard 'Dick' Brunton portrayed by Joel McCrea. Dot, who is unphased by the glitz and glamour of her wealthy lifestyle, comes across Dick at a dangerous incident at the steel mill, where he demonstrates bravery and leadership. Stirred by this breath of fresh air and resolute character, Dot finds herself captivated by Dick's grounded approach to life and quickly decides that he is the man she wants to marry.

However, their distinct societal positions instigate struggles as Dick, a man of independent spirit, grapples with the thought of being a 'kept husband', the seismic shift in lifestyle and the experience of being thrust into an alien environment where he constantly feels out of his depth. As the plot toils forward, the audience witnesses the internal turmoil Richard endures as he wrestles with his values and responsibilities towards his new family and his innate desire for a hard-earned living.

Adding another layer to the narrative, the role of Dot’s parents presents another slice of the high-society mindset. Clara Kimball Young, casting a compelling presence as Mrs. Henrietta Post, embodies the elite class's concerns and values, a stark contrast to Dot's unorthodox choices in life. Furthermore, the portrayal of Mr. Post by Robert McWade nuances the hypocrisy of the affluent class versus the reality of their lives beneath the surface.

On the other hand, Dick's parents are introduced as hardworking middle-class individuals who are not just surprised but also delighted at their son's sudden social upliftment. Dot and Dick's contrasting upbringing and their parents' polarized views set forth an interesting contrast as the plot progresses, feeding into the complexity of the narrative in delightful ways.

Under Lloyd Bacon's capable direction, the film effortlessly magnifies the deeply embedded class disparities in society, and how they intrude upon personal relationships. The sparkling dialogue, combined with the brilliant cinematography, captures the drama, humor, and social critique in a compelling package.

The duo of Mackaill and McCrea forms the heart of the film, stirring emotions and captivating audiences with their outstanding performances. McCrea as the modest yet principled steel mill hero shines in his role. He does a tremendous job at expressing Richard's internal conflicts, capturing the fears and insecurities that come with such an abrupt change in socioeconomic status.

On the other hand, Mackaill brings a desirable warmth and charm to her portrayal of a high-society woman. Her chemistry with McCrea is palpable, and she provides a nuanced performance reflecting Dot's pure intentions yet oblivious privilege.

In addition to the lead pair, Clara Kimball Young and Ned Sparks deliver commendable performances in their respective roles. Young’s portrayal of a stereotypically fretful high society mother adds gravitas to the drill, while Sparks provides some comic relief in his role as McCrea's brusque, no-nonsense boss.

In a nutshell, Kept Husbands successfully explores themes of love, societal critiques, class disparity, and personal values, all wrapped up in a captivating storyline. With its clever scripting, remarkable performances, and insightful direction, the film subtly challenges societal norms while telling a propelling story. It's a classic gem, very much deserving of a watch for those who appreciate early American cinema.