The People vs. George Lucas

The People vs. George Lucas is a fascinating 2010 documentary film directed by Alexandre O. Philippe which takes a deep look at the somewhat tumultuous relationship between acclaimed filmmaker George Lucas and his legions of fans. The film presents a unique mixture of interviews, film clips, and fan creations in order to weave its intriguing narrative.

George Lucas' cultural impact is undeniable, having created Star Wars, one of the most successful and beloved film franchises of all time. However, over the years, Lucas has become a somewhat contentious figure among fans. Many fans have expressed dissatisfaction with his decisions concerning the franchise, particularly the prequel and special edition trilogy. The controversy stems from Lucas' decision to significantly alter the original trilogy for the 1997 Special Editions and DVD releases by adding new scenes, altering others and changing details – all issues intricately examined in The People vs. George Lucas.

The film begins with a confirmation of Lucas' genius and creativity. It explores the humble beginnings of Lucas in Modesto, California, how he created the Star Wars universe that has so significantly influenced popular culture around the globe, and transformed the movie industry with his cutting-edge technology. The film also delves into Lucas' early cinematic triumphs, including the original Star Wars Trilogy and American Graffiti. Interviews with film directors, producers, and experts, including Joe Nussbaum, Daryl Frazetti and Doug Jones, provide valuable insights into Lucas' earlier years and his extraordinary contributions to the movie industry.

However, the centerpiece of the film is the passionate, sometimes visceral response from fans to alterations made to their beloved Star Wars original trilogy. The film is able to weave in an undercurrent of the culture of fandom and ownership, and the blurry lines that define them. It’s through this angle that the film transcends from being a mere dispute about a movie to a broader discussion about the changing dynamics in the relationship between creators and fans in an increasingly interactive and participatory media environment.

There is a fascinating exploration of the Love-Hate relationship that fans have developed towards Lucas over the four decades of Star Wars existence. Should Lucas be vilified for tinkering with his original Star Wars trilogy, which has been elevated to a sacrosanct position by its fans, or is he justified in his claim of it being his creation to modify as he sees fit? Additionally, the film addresses Lucasfilm's complicated relationship with fan films and copyright enforcement, which further stokes the tension between creator and consumer.

The People vs. George Lucas also includes an impressive variety of fan-created content: from animations and stop-motion to parodies and reenactments. This highlights the obsessive passion and dedication Star Wars fans have for the franchise. It's a tribute to their commitment and loyalty and serves as a fascinating lens into the world of fandom.

Through its numerous interviews, a portrait of Lucas begins to take shape that is not as villainous as the title might suggest. This portrayal of Lucas, juxtaposed with the impassioned vitriol of betrayed fans, aims to offer a balanced view of the controversial topics at hand. Many interviewees are quick to both criticize Lucas for his perceived missteps, and also to come to his defense, revealing a complex, almost familial dynamic of love and disappointment.

Philippe’s film is more than a display of disgruntled fans airing their Star Wars grievances—it's a documentary about the consequences of creation, about artistic control in the midst of corporate commercialism, and about the evolving relationship between creators and their audiences in the 21st century.

The People vs. George Lucas is an engaging and thought-provoking documentary, providing a moving examination of fans' complex and sometimes conflicted relationship with one of the most significant figures in film history. The film doesn't pretend to provide definitive answers but rather leaves viewers to consider the questions on their own terms.

For those who love Star Wars, who adore movies, and are interested in the cultural clash between fans and creators, The People vs. George Lucas offers a riveting and illuminating experience. Indeed, the film is as much a tribute to the enduring legacy and power of Star Wars as it is an examination of its controversial creator. It underscores the impact that a powerful story well told can have, and the repercussions when that story is perceived to have been altered or tampered with.