Too Many Girls

Released in 1940, Too Many Girls is a delightful Broadway musical turned silver screen hit, filled with comic humor and memorable song and dance numbers, agricultural allegories, small-town values, and rampant romantic encounters. Packed with numerous comic gags, heart-fluttering romantic scenes, and whimsical musical numbers, the movie is a showcase of the talented Lucille Ball, Richard Carlson, Ann Miller, and other ensemble actors who heighten the charm.

Lucille Ball, with her distinctive comedic talent and charisma, steals the limelight as the spirited and rich college girl named Connie Casey. Her wealthy father, played by the commanding Charles Judels, fears loneliness and over-indulgence may spoil his daughter's life after she goes to college. To ensure her safety and proper upbringing, he hires four strapping young football players from her father’s favorite team, anonymously, to accompany her to Pottawatomie College in Stop Gap, New Mexico. Richard Carlson, Eddie Bracken, Hal Le Roy, and Desi Arnaz are entrusted with this responsibility, with Carlson leading the pack as Clint Kelly, the upright and sensible one among the quartet.

The plot thickens, weaving in a delightful tapestry of well-timed comedy and blossoming romance when these four robust young men unknowingly end up falling for the lively Connie Casey. It’s not long before they find themselves in a tangle of romantic attention towards the resourceful debutante, creating a humorous backdrop that underscores most of the narrative. Known for playing charming and intuitive roles, Richard Carlson plays a pivotal role, becoming the central contender for Connie's attention.

Ann Miller, the radiant Broadway dancer, is featured as Pepe, an energetic college student who also harbors romantic feelings for the dashing Clint Kelly. Her dazzling dance routines and impressive comic timing add spark and spontaneity to the film, making it lively and engaging.

An important aspect of Too Many Girls is the incorporation of song and dance numbers. Produced by RKO Radio Pictures and directed by George Abbott, the film boasts a wealth of catchy tunes and stunning choreographed sequences that not only enhance the storytelling but also maintain the vibe of a Broadway musical. With songs by the eminent American composer Richard Rodgers and lyricist Lorenz Hart, the compelling score and peppy musical sequences add an element of infectious energy that serves to transport the audience back to the same enchanting world of the original Broadway production of "Too Many Girls."

The romantic escapades and lively musical numbers take place against the colorful backdrop of a college in a small New Mexico town, giving a taste of the cherished liberated youth and innocent fun of the time. Lucille Ball, with her comical antics and mischievous screen presence, opens up an engaging narrative about love, friendship, and college life, making the movie a charming blend of comedy and romance.

As an early Lucille Ball film, Too Many Girls offer audiences an opportunity to see the actress before she achieved her iconic status with her role in “I Love Lucy.” Ball’s chemistry with a young Desi Arnaz is palpable and serves as an interesting prelude to their later real-life marriage and legendary television partnership.

Too Many Girls embraces humor, romance, and a bit of drama in its tone while preserving the cheerful school spirit and camaraderie. The film is an interesting mix of talented acting, stimulating music, charming story, and light-hearted humor that'll have you humming a tune by the end. It captures the aura of the 1940s Broadway productions and delivers it delightfully in cinematic style, making it an essential watch for classic movie buffs and fans of Lucille Ball and Richard Carlson.

In essence, Too Many Girls is more than just an enjoyable romp; it is also a charming exposition of the world as seen from the perspective of the early 20th-century youth. It is a time capsule of an era when college life was unburdened and filled with fun, romance, and friendly competition, captured beautifully through a vivacious and comedic presentation that doesn't fail to entertain.