Top Hat and Tales: Harold Ross and the Making of the New Yorker

Top Hat and Tales: Harold Ross and the Making of the New Yorker is a fascinating documentary from 2001, providing an in-depth look into the inception, establishment, and journey of one of the most iconic American magazines, The New Yorker. Directed by Adam Van Doren, the movie is a remarkable tribute to a publication that holds a critical place in U.S. journalism and literature. With a compelling narrative and engaging storytelling, the movie shines a spotlight on Harold Ross, the laudable editor and founder of the New Yorker, and his profound influence on the magazine’s unique style and enduring success.

The film features three main narrators - celebrated authors Stuart Hemple and Roy Blount Jr., and renowned actor Stanley Tucci, who helps bring the story to life with their immersive narration and in-depth knowledge about the magazine and its legacy. Their articulate narration bares the spirit and ethos of the magazine, and paints an enlightening picture of Harold Ross's vision and his indomitable spirit in managing the celebrated magazine.

Top Hat and Tales takes audiences on a captivating journey, detailing the story of the ever-evolving New Yorker from its founding days in the 1920s. Aided by an array of archival footages, the movie paints a vivid picture of Ross’s transformative leadership and how The New Yorker grew to become an influential source of modern American journalism and literature.

The movie also uncovers the unique editorial style of Ross and how it helped to shape and set The New Yorker apart from other publications. Ross’s audacity to break conventions and traditional norms of journalism are captured effectively in the film. His belief in taking creative risks and his unparalleled commitment to provide readers with thought-provoking, intelligent humor are emphasized.

Blount Jr., Hemple, and Tucci lend their firsthand insights into how the New Yorker reflected the cultural shifts of America over the years due to Ross's passion for rigorous journalism. Their anecdotes and thoughts convey Ross’s resolute pursuit of editorial excellence. They recount Ross’s determination to create a platform for delivering both "light" and "serious" content, seamlessly integrating whimsicality with intellectual engagement.

The narratives are further enriched by interviews with notable figures from the literary and journalistic world who delve into the nuances of Ross's editorial philosophy. Their perspectives provide a deeper understanding of the magazine's dedication to fostering quality fiction, long-form reportage, and literary reviews. Not shying away from highlighting the challenges and criticisms faced by Ross, the film gives a well-rounded presentation of his efforts to maintain the essence of The New Yorker amidst changing times.

Moreover, Top Hat and Tales offers a glimpse into the craftsmanship behind The New Yorker’s distinct cover designs and celebrated cartoons. Ross's quest for perfection and his relentless focus on the minutest details of the magazine's design aesthetics are also a focus of the film.

If you are intrigued by the world of publishing, literature, journalism, or if you are a regular follower of The New Yorker, Top Hat and Tales: Harold Ross and the Making of the New Yorker is a must-watch. Even if you do not belong to these categories, the film’s engaging narrative, rich insights, and the appeal of peeping into the legend of Harold Ross and his extraordinary creation is sufficient to hold your attention. It invites viewers to reflect on the role of media in reflecting and shaping societal norms and gives them an opportunity to journey through an important chapter of American cultural history.

In essence, the documentary serves not just as a tribute to Harold Ross and The New Yorker, but also as an exploration of the ongoing dialogue between journalism and society. It is a testament to the enduring power of words, images, and ideas, cementing The New Yorker's reputation as a trusted keeper of the American literary tradition. Its celebration of the magazine reminds us of the importance of well-researched, unbiased, and thought-provoking journalism. And with Ross at the helm, it distinguishes him as a visionary editor whose legacy continues to inspire the magazine's ethos even today.