We Can't Make the Same Mistake Twice

Directed by legendary documentary filmmaker Alanis Obomsawin, We Can't Make the Same Mistake Twice is a poignant, powerful and deeply insightful film that scrutinizes the Canadian government's infringements of the rights of Indigenous children. Centered on the struggles of Indigenous communities, Obomsawin's 50th film uniquely draws attention to the disparities the young experience in the federal government’s provision of public services to Indigenous and non-Indigenous children.

The film was released in 2016, during a pivotal time in Canadian history, where discussions about reconciliation, Indigenous rights and the acknowledgement of historical wrongs were brought to the forefront. Through its captivating narration, We Can't Make the Same Mistake Twice provides a platform for the full and fair hearing in the legal system that the Indigenous community was long denied, embodying the vision of a just society and fostering a much-needed dialogue about social justice issues in Canada.

Emphasizing the importance of safeguarding the rights of future generations, the narrative's focal point veers towards a lawsuit initiated in 2007 by Cindy Blackstock of the First Nations Child and Family Caring Society and the Assembly of First Nations. This unprecedented legal saga unfolded over nine long years. It accused the federal government of willfully underfunding child and family services on First Nations reserves and in the Yukon, resulting in a diminished quality of life and increased risks for those children.

The documentary unflinchingly explores the animosities and disparities, expressed through the voices of those directly influenced and impacted by the political and socio-economical inequalities. It vividly portrays the human side of a prolonged legal struggle, skilfully balancing court proceedings with personal testimonies, provoking substantial thoughts about the broader implications of racial discrimination on the affected community's soul and spirit.

We Can't Make the Same Mistake Twice is an intricately woven narrative, with Obomsawin's expert storytelling binding legal jargon, personal anecdotes, years of struggle, and the Indigenous community's aspiration for justice and equality into a comprehensive, accessible whole. At approximately 2.5 hours, the film may seem lengthy, but it is a testament to the sheer complexity and magnitude of the topic it addresses. It allows the audience to appreciate the profound implications of the lawsuit and its broader impact on Indigenous people's lives.

An essential contribution to the understanding of the disparity in services provided to Indigenous children, Obomsawin's film combines a poignant quest for justice with a profound critique of institutional structures. It is a powerful call to action, resonating beyond the courtroom and demanding a long-awaited change in policies. Throughout, Obomsawin makes use of her signature documentary style, using calm, unhurried camera movements, allowing events to unfold naturally, investing in the individuals she interviews, and allowing them to narrate their experiences.

With a rich, meticulous exploration of systemic injustices and inherent racism, We Can't Make the Same Mistake Twice encapsulates a landmark legal battle as well as the fierce courage, resilience, and determination of the Indigenous community to secure a better and fairer future for their children. Obomsawin's narrative profiles the valiant efforts of those battling a system that has continuously disregarded their rights, quietly urging everyone to acknowledge, respect and protect the rights of every child, irrespective of their ethnicity.

In summary, We Can't Make the Same Mistake Twice is an engaging, transformative and self-reflective movie advocating for change and intelligent discourse. It embodies a promise to future generations that their welfare and well-being are worth fighting for. It aims to enlighten, confront, and inspire. It is not just a documentary that presents a case against the Canadian government; it is a meaningful film that reveals how far society still has to go to establish true equality. It is an important piece of cinema that transposes a crucial moment in Canadian history, a story of struggle and resilience, a tale of dedication to justice, a call for reparation and, above all, a proclamation of love for the Indigenous children of Canada.