Return to Amish

Return to Amish is a richly layered reality television program from TLC that first premiered in 2014. Following in the footsteps of its successful predecessor, Breaking Amish, the show provides a unique glimpse into the lives of a group of men and women who decide to trade their simplistic and technology-free Amish lifestyle for the conveniences and complexities of modern living.

At the core of the show is the exploration of identity and belonging, a theme that resonates both within and outside of the Amish community. The protagonists of the show, both in the original Breaking Amish series and in Return to Amish, grapple with their roots and values as they navigate the unfamiliar terrain of contemporary society.

The series revolves around a select group of individuals who have decided to veer off the path expected of them in their strict and conservative Amish communities and enter the mainstream English world, as they refer to the non-Amish society. Such a decision does not come without substantial internal strife and turmoil. The show delves into the heart-wrenching emotional conflict that they face, torn between their ingrained Amish values and the allure of freedom, technology, and opportunity in English life.

While the show captures the excitement and wonder of initially experiencing aspects of modern society such as cars, electricity, and cell phones, it also reflects the consequences of their choice. Return to Amish depicts the potently heartbreaking isolation and estrangement they encounter as they are often completely shunned by their families and friends who remain in the Amish community - a traditional practice for individuals who leave the community. A remarkable aspect of the show is how it elucidates the dual alienation felt by those who choose to leave - alienation from both the familiar life they've left behind, and the modern world they're struggling to fit into.

Unlike its predecessor, Return to Amish primarily follows the lives of these individuals after they have transitioned into mainstream society. This deeper dimension allows audiences to witness their long-term struggles as they acclimatize to modern living, while the specter of their Amish past looms large. This enduring connection to their origins becomes the crux of the show as some even contemplate returning to the Amish community, despite its rigid restrictions.

It is the characters' journey, both physical and emotional, that forms the heart of Return to Amish. The protagonists represent a wide range of age groups, each with their unique struggles and perspectives on their transitional journey. Their narratives are infused with a storied past, each carrying their personal baggage and tortured histories, which include tales of rebellious youth, marital difficulties, substance abuse issues, and all the consequences of their monumental decision.

Some focus on their new careers and education, choosing to learn English and secure better job prospects, while others may focus on their inter-personal relationships, dealing with the dynamics of forbidden romances outside the Amish community or handling the intricacies of English social conventions.

The show is a tapestry of raw emotions, turbulent journeys, and stark personal transformations. Every episode is imbued with the drama of reality, whether it's mundane activities like buying groceries in a supermarket for the first time or the gripping tension of dealing with rejection from loved ones. Return to Amish offers a tender, empathetic portrayal of this rare cultural transition, steering clear of sensationalism and focusing instead on the human side of the transformative journey.

Diverse in its settings, the show moves from the strict, pastoral tranquillity of Amish country in Pennsylvania to bustling metropolises like New York City. The stark contrast in landscape serves to highlight the magnitude of the cultural shift which the cast experiences by leaving the only lifestyle they've ever known.

With its stirring narratives and emotional depth, Return to Amish is more than a reality TV show; it's a deep dive into the meaning of identity, belief, freedom, love, and the high price of breaking free from tradition. It leaves audiences questioning their own values and preconceived notions while highlighting the concept of adaptation and profound courage that comes with choosing one's own path. It's an enlightening and eye-opening show that pulls back the veil on a fascinating subculture and the individuals who brave leaving it.